//
home

Latest Post

Effect and Cause


A review of a new book recapping 100 Years of the liberal magazine The New RepublicInsurrections of the Mind: 100 Years of Politics and Culture in America goes to something I’ve been trying to say regarding statements to the effect that Republicans in congress are more “extreme” than Democrats. Here are a couple quotes:

“Over the last 25 years, liberalism has lost its good name and its sway over politics,” reads a 2006 statement by TNR editors, with which [Foer] introduces outstanding essays of the 2000s. “But it’s liberalism’s loss of imagination that is most disheartening.” More disheartening, actually, is the preaching of hatred under the guise of liberalism. More disheartening still is Foer’s decision to highlight TNR essays from the previous decade that do just that as if they carry forward liberalism’s noblest traditions.

TNR’s promulgation of hatred of conservative people and ideas — and editor Foer’s showcasing of it in TNR’s 100th anniversary tribute to itself — represent intellectual and moral failure. Not insurrections of the free mind but posturing and preening of the partisan mind.

The trouble with The New Republic is not that it has become too liberal, but that it has not remained, in the more fundamental sense, liberal enough.

The point I’ve been trying to make is that the left is seeing an effect and calling it a cause.

If Republicans really are as extreme as the left says they are (and I don’t concede that point), then I argue that that extremism is an only-natural response to the actual extremism of the left, evidence of which is mountainous and includes not only the article quoted above, but also, for example, the extremist ramming-through of Obamacare “for our own good” and Harry Reid’s extremist one-man control of practically all of Congress (Senate AND House), described here, here, and here

You can’t commit so much sacrilege (as Haidt describes here) for such a long time against the sacred values of America/Conservatism and then be surprised that there’s a reaction (and THEN blame the reactors!). If Democrats and liberalism had not gone so far off the rails then, I maintain, the “extremism” the left perceives among Republicans and conservatism never would have happened.

I’m a fan of singer/songwriter/performer Jack White. Sometimes a song can capture an idea quite well. Here’s one of his that illustrates what I think Haidt and others are doing when they claim Republicans and/or conservatives are “extreme,” (and by the way, doesn’t the first line about using a problem as an excuse for inventing a contraption sound a lot like another bon mot of liberalism, “never let a crisis go to waste”?) 

“Effect And Cause”

I guess you have to have a problem
If you want to invent a contraption
first you cause a train wreck
And then you put me in traction
well first came an action
And then a reaction
But you can’t switch around
For your own satisfaction
Well you burnt my house down
Then got mad at my reaction

Well in every complicated situation
There’s a human relation
Making sense of it all
Take a whole lot of concentration
Well you can blame the baby
For her pregnant ma
And if there’s one of these unavoidable laws

It’s just that you can’t just take the effect and make it the cause

[Chorus:]

Well you can’t take the effect
And make it the cause
I didn’t rob a bank
because you made up the law
Blame me for robbing peter
Don’t you blame Paul
Can’t take the effect
And make it the cause

I ain’t the reason that you gave me
No reason to return your call
You built a house of cards
And got shocked when you saw them fall
Well I ain’t saying I’m innocent
In fact the reverse
But if your heading to the grave
you Don’t blame the hearse
You’re like a little girl yelling at her brother
Cause you lost his ball

You keep blaming me for what you did
And that ain’t all
The way you clean up the wreck
Is enough to give one pause
You seem to forget just how this song started
I’m reacting to you
because you left me broken hearted

See you just can’t just take the effect and make it the cause

[Chorus]

 

Copyright Notice

  • © The Independent Whig and TheIndependentWhig.com - 2011-2013. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this blog’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to The Independent Whig and TheIndependentWhig.com with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.

Quotes I Like:

"The media tends to be liberal, um, as the academic world is, and Hollywood. So you cannot grow up in this country without being exposed to lots and lots of liberal ideas. But it wasn't until I was about 40 that I happened to pull a book off a shelf that said conservatism on it that I was ever exposed to conservative ideas. And I'm well educated. And I had never encountered conservative ideas. So, there's a real asymmetry in access to the other side’s ideas."

From an interview of Jonathan Haidt on On Being, with Krista Tippett Used in This Post.

Venn Diagram of Liberal and Conservative Moral Foundations

Enter your email address to follow The Independent Whig and receive notifications of new posts by email.

An Interpretation of Jonathan Haidt’s Moral Foundations Theory

This sidebar lists a series of posts which together make up an essay relating Moral Foundations Theory to today's politics, and even a little history, as viewed through The Independent Whig's six-foundation moral lens.

Categories

Venn Diagram of Liberal and Conservative Moral Foundations

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.